How do you determine data authorship?
05/12/2016
When a dataset is published online, the depositor must enter some information about it, including providing details about its authors. It seems an innocuous field to fill in, but determining data authorship can be complex – how do you choose which team members to list?
Well, what are the implications of data authorship? The data authors are the people who will be credited when the dataset is cited in publications or other further works, so it is important that all the people who deserve such credit are included. The authors might also be contacted if inaccuracies are found or there are queries about the data that need answering, so they should have the necessary familiarity with the work.
So who should be listed as data authors if there is a large research team? Everyone? Just the person who collected the data? What about the person who, for example, designed the questionnaire or experiment? Or did the quality checks on the data? Or spent time formatting and documenting it for it to be shared for reuse? Or a senior colleague whose contribution in project conception, oversight and steering was crucial, but who never did any day-to-day data work?
Unfortunately, this post is not going to answer those questions, as there are no hard and fast rules. Generally, it is important that anyone who made a significant intellectual or practical contribution to the data’s creation is credited, but how this principle is applied may vary. Two frequent cases are whether or not to credit people who have done legwork in data collection, but made no intellectual contribution to it, and whether or not to include those who steered the project but never worked with the data. It can be useful to consider what is standard in your domain, and any guidance from publishers or funders. In your data management plan, you should be setting out which datasets will be published and where, so this may also be a good opportunity to clarify who will be listed as the authors, to avoid any delays to publication if there are queries over who to name.
For further discussion of the issues, the Research Data Alliance and CODATA have just published a report on the Principles and Implementation Guidelines for Legal Interoperability of Research Data (pdf) with Principle Six (starting p.25) particularly relevant to the discussion on authorship. Do you think these are useful guidelines? Are there standard practices in your research community around data authorship, or are there questions that need discussing?
Image: Rock, Paper, Scissors by Jesse Kruger, CC-BY-NC 2.0, at https://www.flickr.com/photos/jessekruger/464375923/
Categories & Tags:
Leave a comment on this post:
You might also like…
Systematic Literature Review – Identifying your search terms and constructing your search strings
Our previous posts on the systematic review have looked at getting started and selecting your sources. In this post we will look at the next fundamental stage: Identifying your search terms and constructing your search ...
Navigating the World of Robotics: My Journey at Cranfield University
Hey there, I'm Manideep, and I'm thrilled to share my experience pursuing an MSc in Robotics at Cranfield University. Let me take you through my journey and how Cranfield became the ...
Exploring safer and smarter airports with the Applied Artificial Intelligence MSc group design project
Artificial intelligence (AI) technologies have experienced rapid development in recent years, spanning from large language models (LLMs) to generative artificial intelligence (GAI). These cutting-edge advancements have significantly impacted various aspects of ...
My aerospace manufacturing journey at Cranfield University
Hey there, I'm Abhishek and I wanted to share my journey into aerospace manufacturing, guided by my experiences at Cranfield University. Let's dive into how this remarkable institution shaped my career ...
Changes to Library Services over Easter, 29 March – 1 April
Libraries on the Cranfield site Both Kings Norton Library and the School of Management Library (Building 111, first floor) will be open 24/7 over the Easter weekend. You will be able to use the study ...
How to present well as a group
You will have put a lot of work into your research or project and want to show everyone what you have achieved or discovered, so you need to impart this knowledge as clearly as possible. ...