Ensuring ‘Straw Men’ survive: creating a relevant and rigorous safety research project
31/05/2017

“It’s great to be back!” was the concluding comment in an email following a recent meeting of the Advisory Group for our IOSH funded research project investigating the safety management of contractors.
Designing a research project that provides useful practical insights and simultaneously generates robust empirical data to test and develop theory is no small challenge. And one that I don’t think we achieved on our last project, but hopefully we can succeed this time round. That’s where our Advisory Group of experienced practitioners can play their part: making suggestions, challenging our ideas and keeping us mindful of what really matters to practice. No academic ‘flights of fancy’ would satisfy them.
So I was more than a little apprehensive as I set out my ‘straw men’ in the meeting. Would they make sense? Would they be sufficiently interesting? Were they relevant? What if they were incinerated in an instant?
Our successful project launch event in February has identified several important issues and since then I had worked hard to marry them to existing theoretical problems I’d identified in the academic literature. I had succeeded in finding four topics that I thought might work. And now they faced their first test. Fingers-crossed.
If contractors work with a client organization how do they share the knowledge that each possesses? And what in particular stops this sharing? No real problem with this particular ‘straw man’. However, knowledge might be really ‘sticky’ inside either organization. Those that conduct the initial negotiations are not the same people that do the job. And they don’t appear to talk to each other.
My second ‘straw man’ suggested that clients and contractors might see each other as different groups. So what sorts of tension occur between them? How are these managed? They were bound to agree with this, weren’t they? Of course, but discussion did highlight the subtle (or not so subtle) ways in which contractors are not embraced by the client organization. Are they housed in the 1950’s Nissen Hut or the brand new office block? And who holds the door open for whom?
Things were going well – two successes. The last discussion led nicely into the third topic – the management of psychological safety. Do these relationships between contractor and client allow everyone to thrive? Or are they selective? Some thrive, others merely survive. For example, what do health-care facilities do contractors have access to when they are on-site? Can they access the fitness centre or the confidential well-being service?
Could we make it to lunch without a heap of ashes? Safety leadership is a buzz word and no-one really knows that it means. But in a client-contractor relationship is leadership shared or distributed between both parties, or does one simply dictate to the other? It could be shared. It might need to be shared if the contract lasts for several years and both groups want to meet their desired objectives. The Advisory Group certainly encouraged us to investigate how and whether consensus is achieved.
Phew – my ‘straw men’ made it unscathed, but with plenty to think about. Meanwhile the advisors left happy that they’d had a good debate and glad that we’d been left with trying to make sense of a complex and inter-related set of problems.
I can’t wait for the next meeting.
Categories & Tags:
Leave a comment on this post:
You might also like…
Working on your group project? We can help!
When undertaking a group project, typically you'll need to investigate a topic, decide on a methodology for your investigation, gather and collate information and data, share your findings with each other, and then formally report ...
Words matter – a conversational Integrated Vehicle Health Management lexicon
There are many well established barriers to successful digital transformation which prevent full realisation of desired benefits. It is generally recognised that only 30% of digital transformation efforts deliver these results. One of the ...
Library support for new research students
Welcome! We are very excited to welcome you to Cranfield, and we are looking forward to supporting you throughout your research degree. We are always happy to help you – all you need to do ...
Finding full-text Economist articles…
If you’re looking for The Economist, the place to go is ProQuest One Business. Follow these step-by-step instructions to get full-text access. Login here and click on the Publications option at the top, above the ...
New IEEE route to gold open access for UKRI-funded research
You probably know by now that if you publish a paper that acknowledges funding from UKRI (including Innovate UK) it must be made open access immediately upon publication with a CC-BY licence. To remind you, ...
OnePetro subscription ending 5 February
Our access to OnePetro will cease at the beginning of February. This database contains full text documents from professional societies that serve the oil and gas industry. It has experienced a significant drop in usage ...