Report warns universities are in danger of stifling their own success
New research conducted by Cranfield School of Management on behalf of the Leadership Foundation for Higher Education (LFHE) shows that, in response to pressures to perform, universities may in fact be damaging their own future success.
The research reveals that universities are becoming more controlling, taking what is known as “an agency approach”, focussing their performance management processes on shorter-term goals and becoming more results and output driven. Whilst this may sound sensible, these approaches are linked to lower levels of staff wellbeing and poorer levels of institutional research excellence.
Universities that adopt a more traditional view, known as a “stewardship approach”, see themselves as stewards of knowledge and education and focus on the longer term development of knowledge for the greater good of society. They create an environment based on autonomy, trust and shared values. The research showed that this approach is associated with higher levels of staff wellbeing as well as higher students’ satisfaction. Higher staff well being is associated with better student employability, with research excellence and also with better financial results.
Report author Dr Monica Franco Santos, Senior Research Fellow at Cranfield School of Management said: “UK Universities are at a tipping point. Whilst it is understandable that they are adopting a shorter term, results focussed approach owing to pressures to perform better and a reduction in financial resources, they run the risk of failing to deliver their long-term mission. Our report recommends the need to craft a hybrid performance management approach that balances stewardship and agency practices and is appropriate to the institution’s own distinctive characteristics.”
The research included insights from more than 1,000 staff, both academic and administrative, working in UK Higher Education Institutions and 110 detailed interviews.
The report is co-authored by Dr Monica Franco-Santos from Cranfield School of Management, Dr Pilar Rivera from the University of Zaragoza and Professor Mike Bourne from Cranfield School of Management.
The research was based on case studies and a substantial survey of staff in Higher Education establishments. More specifically: –
- Case studies were used to look at the performance management mechanisms in six universities. The research looked at three Russell Group and three post-1992 universities focusing on both its academic and administrative staff. This included interviewing 110 key informants from across institutions, from Vice Chancellors to front line staff in central services and in four schools/faculties (Education, Math, Business & Management, and Art).
- A survey of university staff was conducted obtaining over 1000 usable responses. The results from the survey were combined with other publicly available data, from the National Student Satisfaction survey, the last Research Assessment Exercise, the Higher Education Statistics Agency (HESA), and the Universities and College Union’s (UCU) academic staff wellbeing survey.
Link to report
Monica Franco-Santos, Pilar Rivera & Mike Bourne, (2014), “Performance Management in UK higher Education Institutions: The need for a hybrid approach”. http://lnkd.in/bT8dgef
Categories & Tags:
Leave a comment on this post:
You might also like…
Resource trial: Access government policy documents with Overton
Library Services has set up trial access to Overton until 16 April. Overton contains over 7 million policy documents and guidelines from over 31,000 organisations across 180+ countries. The database includes grey literature from leading ...
Life as a MSc Automotive Engineering Student at Cranfield University
I chose Cranfield University, because of its immense industrial connections and the depth of the modules. Before accepting the offer, I had a chat with a few alumni about their life here, both academically ...
My Experience as a C4D Scholar
How the C4D Scholarship made it possible for me to study MDes Design Thinking at one of the most prestigious universities in the world; Cranfield! I first found my interest in Design while in ...
Marketing sustainability claims: How to avoid greenwashing
As businesses strive to market themselves to best appeal to today’s sustainability-conscious consumers, it is perhaps inevitable that claims will be made that don’t necessarily give the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the ...
Representing Cranfield at the edie Sustainable Leaders Conference
I'm Caroline Harris, and I work for the Sustainable Business Group and the Bettany Centre of Entrepreneurship. As the Event Coordinator for both teams, I focus on creating and increasing engagement and outreach both internally ...
The importance of words in neurodiversity
The words we use in studying neurodiversity are important. It's easy to get caught up in the conversation about words. This is often generated by not wanting to cause offense or being in search of ...