Justin Case and Risk Management?
04/07/2019
Have any of you come across this ubiquitous fellow “Justin Case”? He seems to raise his ugly head every time someone suggests trying something new. “Oh, we can’t change that process, Just-in Case the regulator gives us a poor grading!”, I’ve heard people say. Or, “We have to have separate quality checks, Just-in Case there’s a health & safety problem!”. Or, “We can’t ask staff to stop doing that as we had a real problem once where somebody almost got injured so the Unions won’t allow us to stop”.
The real issue is 2 fold;
- People engage their biases (see Daniel Kahneman, Thinking Fast & Slow) as soon as they’re challenged. Kahneman (in his book) talks primarily about System 1 and System 2. System 1 involves the emotional side of our personality as opposed to System 2 – our logical or rational side. The emotional side is not bad, most of the time it’s actually doing its job (to keep the host alive!). By design the brain rapidly develops potentially harmful situations to avoid!
- Very few people are educated (if at all) on how to properly assess or, dare I say it, calculate RISK!
These two factors are a real road-block to improving or transforming an organisation, creating reasons for not doing anything.
The picture above sums up pretty well how to properly visualise risk in a simple format most people could understand in their heads! Referring back to Kahneman, this is engaging system 2!
We have even witnessed a company turning down a contract through not hosting desensitised police data on a server, Just-in Case, staff could be held at gunpoint in their car park and threatened by criminals wanting access to this data! In 2018 IBM reported the average cost per loss of stolen data to be $3.8M of which 48% was through a malicious or criminal attack ($1.57M) and 9% was in the UK ($141,300). None of these thefts was reported within the Criminal Justice arena. Also the majority of these thefts would presumably have happened through online hacking (further reducing the probability that you are not safe in the carpark!). Further, on checking all sources I knew or read about who were involved in police data (including highly sensitive data), no-one had come across any criminals threatening staff in order to gain access to data! So the chances are as close to 0 as you can get. But, being safety biased (something else from Kahneman), let’s borrow a well-known probability which is well-known in the airline industry. The probability of dying in an airplane crash is 0.00002%. Using this number we can actually calculate the maximum risk to the organisation;
Risk = Probability x Loss
< 0.00002% x $141,300
< $0.028
So even if this was calculated on an hourly or daily basis this contract would probably have been worth it! But I bet that company flies people around the world without giving it a thought!
Seems to me, the picture above says it quite clearly – you have to look at the probability as well as the impact (or loss) – and rather than engaging the high-cost Just-in Case, just engage proper risk management!
Categories & Tags:
Leave a comment on this post:
You might also like…
Come to a virtual study session in May
What are virtual study sessions? These are online study sessions facilitated by Library staff, where you can study independently alongside other students via Teams. They are a great way for you to dedicate specific time ...
Getting started on your School of Management thesis
Writing a thesis, business plan, internship project or company project can be a daunting task, and you might have some uncertainty or questions around how to get started. This post will share some ideas and ...
Sustainability by royal request: Managing an event fit for a King
The Coronation of King Charles III on May 6th 2023, was watched by millions of people around the world with tens of thousands of people travelling to Central London to witness the pageantry firsthand. ...
Getting started on your Master’s thesis
Please note: This post is intended to provide advice to all students undertaking a thesis in the Schools of Aerospace, Transport and Manufacturing; Water, Energy and Environment, and Defence and Security. There is separate advice ...
Finding your tribe: “Joining the sustainability community was the best decision”
For students on Cranfield’s Sustainability Business Specialist Apprenticeship, community and camaraderie is a vital component for success. Designed in consultation with industry, the part-time Level 7 apprenticeship aims to deepen participants’ knowledge of the ...
“My sustainability studies gave me the confidence to take on Amazon”
Not everyone would have the confidence to challenge a big global power like Amazon but, for Colin Featherstone, Senior Technology Manager and Tech Sustainability Lead at Morrisons, his Cranfield studies equipped him with the ...