Health Targets a Blunt Instrument
10/07/2014

This morning on Radio 4’s Today programme, Clare Marx, the new President of the Royal College of Surgeons has argued for a review of the NHS 18 week GP referral to treatment target. She called the target a blunt instrument.
I didn’t think I would ever argue this, but I like it because it is a blunt instrument.
The 18 week target has been round a long time, since the government before last. People know what it is and what it means. Is it perfect? No it isn’t and Clare Marx is absolutely right in saying that for many complaints it is too long.
But I look at it the other way. I saw this as a line in the sand that stopped waiting lists growing forever. It is a minimum standard that has to be achieved. It is fine to say that some complaints can wait, but in reality I know cases where the 18 week target was breached and then the patient has found out that the complaint has become in operable because it was seen as minor without proper investigation and diagnosis.
Yes we need to reduce waiting time for many treatments and we should do this. But the 18 week target is so useful for me because it is blunt, people know about it, it has been around a long time and it creates a back stop. I think we remove it at our peril.
Mike Bourne
Categories & Tags:
Leave a comment on this post:
You might also like…
Exploring the skies and beyond: My experience as a GREAT Scholar at Cranfield University
A place where innovation meets practice Cranfield University is renowned for its world-class facilities and resources. What stands out most to me though, is its unique connection to the aerospace industry. ...
Shifting Gears: How virtual prototyping is driving the future of automotive and motorsport
The roar of the engine, the thrill of the track, the relentless pursuit of perfection – these are the hallmarks of racing cars. But even in the world of high-octane performance, ...
How to get the most out of our Open Day
Our Open Day is just around the corner, and you’re wondering what you can do to make sure you get the most out of your visit to us. Fear not, we've pulled together our top ...
Top tips to help you prepare for our Open Day
Our Open Days offer a fantastic opportunity for you to really get a feel for the community here at Cranfield, and we want you to get the best out of it. We’ve got so much ...
Introducing… the UK Data Service (UKDS)
If you’re looking for a gateway to key economic and social data, then you might like to take a look at the UK Data Service (UKDS). What's included? Offering a wide range of secondary data ...
Creating a bibliography is easy in Mendeley
If you’re using Mendeley Cite, Mendeley's citation plug-in for Word, you will soon be ready to generate a bibliography of all the references you have cited. Here we’ll run through how quick and easy it ...