Forecasting – Prediction is very difficult, especially if it’s about the future!
10/07/2017

Niels Bohr, the Nobel laureate in Physics and father of the atomic model, is quoted as saying, “Prediction is very difficult, especially if it’s about the future!” This quote serves as a warning of the importance of testing a forecasting model out-of-sample. It’s often easy to find a model that fits the past data well — perhaps too well! — but quite another matter to find a model that correctly identifies those features of the past data which will be replicated in the future.
So here’s the thing: in the private and public sector, we keep hearing senior executives talking about being more predictive — getting on the front-foot and being less reactive. Almost all of them fail to recognise that unless your business processes, their incoming demand and outgoing outcomes are not “In Control” (meaning in statistical control) then forecasting is worthless — a black art at best! Here’s an example of a process that is not In Control:
The above processes (there are 2 of them, with a change near the middle of the chart causing a “process break” between the first part of the process and the second part of the process) are not In Control. The chart has a large number of different types of signals, red x indicating unusually long delivery times, green x indicating unusually short delivery times, green • indicating sustained unusually short delivery times and red • indicating sustained unusually long delivery times. Using this data to forecast forwards will produce at best a range of between 80 and 200 (lower and upper red performance corridor guidelines on right part of chart), but because it’s not In Control, there will be occasions when these guidelines will be exceeded. This is because, as Niels Bohr says, the signals indicate that the process contains features that may or may not be replicated in the future.
Looking at a process that is In control:
We can see that there are no signals and that the data is following a very strong seasonal pattern. This means the results are likely to be dominated by features of the past that will be replicated in the future. So we can confidently (but not with absolute certainty — there’s always risk, but in this case it is minimised by being In Control) predict what will happen in the future (unless we or the system we are examining make changes):
Thus, we can be pretty sure that the forecast for February 2015 will be around an average (green line bounded by upper and lower red guidelines) of 9,750+500 approx., and for July 2015 will be around an average of 12,500+500 approx.
BUT, if a senior executive says, “I need you to be more precise, I need one number”, you’re up against another well-respected Physicist — Heisenberg and his Uncertainty Principle. The more precise one thing you measure, the fuzzier another becomes. So asking for a forecast which is a single number only (without a range of possible values), means that the probability of it actually occurring approaches zero! Or as Dilbert says, worthless!
Categories & Tags:
Leave a comment on this post:
You might also like…
Three ways to keep up to date with new papers in your favourite journals, and save time!
For as long as I can remember (and that is a long time!) Zetoc has been a tried and trusted source used by researchers to help them stay current with new papers in their favourite ...
Protected: Can you dig it at Glastonbury 2022
This content is password protected. To view it please enter your password below: Password:
Are you being disturbed by noise in the Library?
We want you to be able to study comfortably in all our libraries. At the Kings Norton Library we have been working hard to reduce ongoing problems with noise. Please work in the zone that ...
The efficacy of 3rd generation photovoltaics for Application Targeted Integrated PV applications (ATIP)
My name is Dr. Sagar M. Jain, Senior lecturer and lead in photovoltaics and optoelectronics, Centre for Renewable Energy Systems (CRES), Cranfield University, UK Photovoltaics need to be integrated on various infrastructures and for ...
Digitising the Cranfield University Photo Archive
We are delighted to announce that we have been awarded a scoping grant to help us digitise more of our Photographic Archive and make the images available online. The grant has been provided by Archives ...
Too much to do? Can’t get your thoughts down on paper?
Our Study Skills Hub has two sections that may be able to help you! In Time Management we have some great tips on how to manage your time, to prioritise, and de-stress. First of all, ...