Black Box Thinking, or Learning from Failure
06/09/2017
We were just reflecting at the latest Round Table on Matthew Syed’s book “Black Box Thinking” (2015, John Murray Publishing, London) and in particular on learning from failure.
So what I have done here is pull out some of the lessons which are really relevant for organisational learning. Syed compares the learning culture of the US Health Care Industry with the Aviation Industry and talks a lot about transparency, openness, reporting and the opportunity to learn from mistakes. The quote I really love is from Sullenberger (page 44) reflecting on his UA Airways Flight in 2009 which he “successfully” landed in the Potomac River after losing all his engines in a bird strike.
“Everything we know in aviation, every rule book, every procedure we have, we know because someone, somewhere died … We have purchased at great cost, lessons literally bought with blood that we have to preserve as institutional knowledge and pass on to succeeding generations. We cannot have the moral failure of forgetting these lessons and have to relearn them.”
Syed also talks about organisations being open to learning or not.
“For our purpose, a closed loop is where failure doesn’t lead to progress as information on errors or weaknesses is misinterpreted or ignored; an open loop does lead to progress because the feedback is rationally acted upon.” (page 15)
From the book we also distilled a list of reasons why organisations don’t learn.
- Lack of failure
- Sometimes caused because you haven’t failed
- Sometimes caused because you play safe so avoid failure
- Blame culture
- Feedback
- Speed of feedback – the faster the better
- Clarity of feedback – so you can’t fudge the issue
- Granularity of the evidence – ditto
- Lack of retrospective review – do you do post investment reviews?
- Hierarchy
- A problem is when knowledge is handed down not discovered
- Culture of “inconvenient evidence”
- Top down v bottom up learning
- Language of a profession
- Is it an Error or complication? If the latter, you are obfuscating the fact a failure occurred
- Limit of an investigation
- Ask the “5 Whys”
And finally, some challenging questions to ask yourself about whether or not you learn as an individual. Syed’s comment is if you answer no to any of the following, then you are not open to learn!
- Do you fail in your judgements?
- Do you ever get access to the evidence that shows where you might be going wrong?
- Are your decisions ever challenged by objective data?
Mike Bourne
Categories & Tags:
Leave a comment on this post:
You might also like…
My Apprenticeship Journey – Broadening Horizons
Laura, Senior Systems Engineer at a leading aircraft manufacturing company, joined Cranfield on the Systems Engineering Master’s Apprenticeship after initially considering taking a year off from her role to complete an MSc. Apprenticeship over MSc? ...
The Library app is back!
The Library app is back! It's exactly the same as before (although it will get a fresh look in a few months) and if you hadn't removed it from an existing device it should just ...
PhD researcher at the IF Oxford Science and Ideas Festival
IF Oxford is a science and ideas Festival packed with inspiring, entertaining and immersive events for people all ages. PhD researcher, Zahra attended the festival. Here she shares what motivated her to get involved. ...
What leadership skills are required to meet the demands of digitalisation?
Digital ecosystems are shifting the dynamics of the world as we know it. With digitalisation being a norm in the software industry, there is currently a rapid rise in its translation ...
My PhD experience within the Centre for Air Transport at Cranfield University
Mengyuan began her PhD in the Centre for Air Transport in October 2022. She recently shared what she is working on and how she has found studying at Cranfield University so ...
In the tyre tracks of the Edwardian geologists
In April 1905 a group of amateur geologists loaded their cumbersome bicycles on to a north-bound train at a London rail station and set off for Bedfordshire on a field excursion. In March 2024 a ...
Mike, Some very good comments and observations here that complement the book review we did late last year. You see these sorts of failures every day – just last night I was watching the News and the report was about the plight of the Rohingya Muslims being subjected to genocide or clear out by the regime in Myanmar, and the relatively new President Aung San Suu Kyi (thought of as a saviour of human rights) essentially denying it is happening.