Beyond Budgeting… A journey towards real customer service
18/07/2017

Over the past two years or so, a fellow Visiting Fellow – Steve Morlidge – has been introducing me to the term and benefits of “Beyond Budgeting”. This has provided one major “Ah-ha! Moment”. It also chimes with work we have done with Cranfield in developing what we call a “Systems Approach to Project Management” (more of that in a later blog).
Budgeting and Project Planning (particularly large projects) have a lot in common, four of which are:
- They lay out some form of forecast of revenue, costs, profit based on last year’s results plus expectations of stakeholders on the one hand, and on the other forecast of timeframe and spend, along with projected benefits both based on certain assumptions
- Both the Budget and the Project Plan assume that nothing changes in the system (e.g. the environment, markets, technology etc.) and that expectations and requirements remain cast in concrete over the life-time of the budget or the plan
- They are then used by the executive team to track, on the one hand, how revenue, costs and profit are varying (i.e. variance) from budget (like the budget was God-given and correct), and on the other how deliverables are being delivered along with consumption of effort, materials etc. (cost), and projected expenditure to completion against the project plan (like it was God-given and correct)
- By locking-in the budget or project plan in this way (where it is immoveable) THE ONLY PARAMETER YOU CAN ADJUST IS personal (or team) performance – and hence we get into the perversions of personal (or team) incentives and rewards! My Ah-ha! moment (many thanks Steve!)
So the crux to Beyond Budgeting (as well as Planning) is to accept that:
- Assumptions made may be wrong or change
- The world-system and expectations/requirements may change – particularly as budgets and plans span timeframes typically far longer than the timeframes in which the environment/requirements change
- That in budgeting and planning we, as humans (see Daniel Kahneman, Thinking Fast & Slow) always have an optimism bias
And the crux is that in order to be “agile” or “responsive” (as all the big four consulting firms are telling us we need to be IN ORDER TO STAY IN BUSINESS) we can only do so if budgeting and planning functions accept the above.
So how do you track progress in this moving feast – next blog…
Categories & Tags:
Leave a comment on this post:
You might also like…
Jubilee weekend opening hours for Library services
Library services will change over the weekend of Thursday 2 until Sunday 5 June for the Queen's Platinum Jubilee. Kings Norton Library and Management and Resource Centre (MIRC) Both library spaces will be open for ...
‘Meet the bees’ tour May 2022
When I started working at Cranfield University in March 2021, a couple of the things that I really liked were the amount of green spaces and their dedication to become more environmentally friendly. I’ve never ...
Introducing…. Orbis BankFocus
For anyone researching the financial sector, Orbis BankFocus is a great place to start, providing financial and company data for finance institutions and companies. The service allows you to search for a single company or ...
Me, myself, and anxiety
Then and now I remember the moment very well – I was sat at a desk talking to my boss, pointing out the key elements of a strategic plan. I was in quite a stressful ...
“My Cranfield degree transformed me as a person”
Kalyani Hedge (Management MSc, 2021), is currently working as the Head of Supply Chain, Administration and Legal at Nandu Chemicals Private Limited. We caught up with Kalyani to find out more about her experiences ...
“Studying at Cranfield encouraged me to move out of my comfort zone”
For marketing professional Jim Davies, studying for a part-time MSc in Marketing and Leadership at Cranfield School of Management was the catalyst for making a bold career move after more than a decade spent ...