Why Performance Reporting is NOT Performance Management!
03/04/2017

“Mirror, mirror on the wall whose presentation is the fairest of them all?”
“GDP last quarter is higher than the previous quarter, and the same quarter last year”, says Kamal Ahmed of the BBC News. So far his reporting is correct. “Therefore it’s improving!”, and that’s where his performance management is wrong! The accurate thing that he can say looking at GDP data like this is “Therefore it’s different!”
There’s a massive chasm between reporting what has happened in the past and claiming it tells us about performance management – i.e. about what is likely to happen going forward. Let’s look at 3 aspects of this little conundrum:
- How can we better understand what has happened in the past (in order to take more appropriate action going forward)
- What can we say about what is likely to happen going forward (with/without any intervention)
- What are the fundamental differences between Performance Reporting and Performance Management
Let’s go back to Kamel Ahmed, and to keep things less controversial for this piece, we’ll look at GDP for the UK (figures from the World Bank – and let’s not get into which sources of figures best suit what position we want to take, or who can present the fairest of them all) on an annual basis up to and including 2011. The first thing you’ll notice is (refer back to previous posts on this matter) we are not showing % increases. The misleading reporting we hear and see around the %GDP increase this period (month, quarter, year) is x% better than last period – as if there is some God-given right that %GDP should always be increasing (we are living in a finite world!). If this was indeed the case, then we would be see raw GDP increase exponentially! That looks something like this:
This would mean infinite raw GDP sometime soon. “Unrealistic!” you might say!
So what does raw GDP actually look like:
Interesting! I only have the figures back to 1993, but you have to start somewhere! We are showing the annual figures within trended (Extended-SPC, see previous posts) guidelines – and it is the pattern and trend we should look at as much as the actual individual annual results. We can see up until the credit boom in the early 2000s GDP was trending upwards at about £100bn per year (not unhealthy!). Then GDP dipped around the bursting of the “dotcom bubble”, around 2000 – 2002, and then went nuts with the credit fuelled economy. Then there was a correction (some say disaster, but, as I say, we are living in a finite world!) around 2007/2008. And guess what, the following 3 years where everyone thought we were in “plateau-land” (percentages!) GDP returned to the previous upward trend established in the earlier part of the chart.
Is this a better way of looking at Performance in order to understand it? I’ll leave that with the reader …. and next time we’ll have a look at house prices in the same way, and see if we can see a pattern. After that? We’ll attempt to answer the final two questions posed above…
David Anker
Categories & Tags:
Leave a comment on this post:
You might also like…
From taxidermy to forensic investigation: My journey at Cranfield
Christina Recheis completed her MSc in Forensic Investigation at Cranfield University in 2021 and specialised in forensic archaeology and anthropology. Her master's thesis focused on developing an algorithm to facilitate the identification of human remains, ...
Country stability and risk in BMI Research
If you need to know about country stability and risk, there are two Library services you ought to be looking at BMI Research. Country Risk report in BMI Research BMI covers country ...
How to present well as a group
You will have put a lot of work into your research or project and want to show everyone what you have achieved or discovered, so you need to impart this knowledge as clearly as possible. ...
Exploring the skies and beyond: My experience as a GREAT Scholar at Cranfield University
A place where innovation meets practice Cranfield University is renowned for its world-class facilities and resources. What stands out most to me though, is its unique connection to the aerospace industry. ...
Creating a new user account in Mendeley
Before you start using Mendeley reference management software, you will need to create an account. This is a really simple process and should take you no more than a couple of minutes. Just follow the ...
Shifting Gears: How virtual prototyping is driving the future of automotive and motorsport
The roar of the engine, the thrill of the track, the relentless pursuit of perfection – these are the hallmarks of racing cars. But even in the world of high-octane performance, ...