Hard Metrics and Soft Culture
19/09/2017
Cranfield is in the process of introducing a new faculty contribution system as part of the performance development review process (PDR). As part of that discussion, yesterday we were talking about the metrics and how they would be used to manage faculty.
Prof Hugh Wilson came up with this phrase, “Hard Metrics and Soft Culture”, which I took to. He was talking about having more facts on which to base the PDR, more real information about what people had done and contributed during the previous year. But he was also talking about how we go about motivating people and doing the development side of the review, rather than just looking at so called “contribution”.
We know from all the research we have done in the Centre for Business Performance that measurement doesn’t improve performance. By itself it does absolutely nothing. It is all about how we use the measures.
Are they sticks to beat people with? In that case they may have a limited positive effect for a short period of time but eventually this approach is doomed to failure. Are they ways of motivating us? This may be laudable, but I would argue that it is a short term solution and, although more acceptable, doomed to failure.
Measurement only makes a difference if it is used to change something that itself will improve performance. That may be the way we work, the improvement in the skills and experience of our staff, the systems we use, the processes we run. It may be that we focus on some things and not on others. But it is the reflection, learning and action that is so important. The rest is just administrative overhead.
Next time I will discuss “Soft Metrics and Hard Culture”.
Mike Bourne
Categories & Tags:
Leave a comment on this post:
Comments are closed.
You might also like…
Bank holiday hours for Library Services: Monday 31 August
Library Services staff will be taking a break on Monday 31 August for the bank holiday. You will still be able to access all the resources and help you need via our library website. The 24/7 ...
The real cost of studying in the UK – what international students need to budget for
Moving overseas to pursue a postgraduate degree is one of the most exciting investments you can make in your future. It's also one of the most significant financial commitments you and your family will ...
Seven things you should definitely prepare for before studying at Cranfield University
You're thinking about Cranfield. Maybe you've done the virtual tour, read through the course pages, spoken to the course director or attended a webinar. Now, you're trying to figure out what life here is actually ...
From insurance to aerospace: why I chose to study a PhD with Cranfield
My path to studying for a PhD wasn't exactly a straight line. I had just graduated with an MEng in Aerospace Engineering from the University of Surrey and, like a lot of people, wasn't ...
How to build a business that keeps growing
Ask any business owner about their ambitions and "growth" will almost certainly feature near the top of the list. More customers, higher revenues, larger teams and new markets are often seen as signs of ...
Three practical ways SMEs can build resilience in a challenging business environment
Economic uncertainty, shifting customer expectations and rapid technological change have become part of everyday business. While no organisation can predict every challenge, small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) can improve their resilience by focusing on ...
Mike, Nice observations here! Two points:
1. There are some managers who get measurement mixed up with setting targets/rewards, and in so doing the measures get bastardised to suit certain political aims rather than the good aims of the organisation, and can encourage obtuse behaviour to meet targets rather than understand and improve an organisation’s performance.
2. We’ve found extrinsic (i.e. use of targets) motivation of individuals is short-term and often damaging (per above), and have found that by using a so-called “Outcomes Framework” that links the organisation’s Purpose to Actions at the front-line enabling individuals to see clearly how their contribution impacts Purpose – this generates intrinsic motivation (most of the time) and is much more sustainable.